Skip to content

Best Proto-Science Fiction

Best of the Really Old Stuff Before Science Fiction was a Genre

See the ranking

'Proto-Science Fiction' being science fiction books written before HG Wells (pre 1890. Also referred to as the 'really old stuff before science fiction was even a genre.

If you value your sanity, stay away from all those places where critics argue about what was the first science fiction story. No one agrees. Brian Aldiss famously said that Mary Shelley's Frankenstein was the first, but that's because he defined science fiction in such a way that nothing before then could count. Gary Westfahl insists that science fiction could not begin until authors recognised that they were working within a genre, so science fiction really begins with Hugo Gernsback's Amazing Stories. And there are all sorts of other works, between these dates or much earlier, that other critics have proclaimed.

You see, it all depends on how we define science fiction. And since it is impossible to come up with a definition that everyone agrees on, so it is inevitably impossible to come up with a starting point that everyone agrees on.

All we know for sure is that as long ago as the second century of the Christian Era there were at least two works in which travellers visited the moon. One was A True History by Lucian of Samosata, and the other was The Incredible Wonders Beyond Thule by Antonius Diogenes, which probably was earlier though it has been lost so we don't really know much about it. There could well have been others, we just don't know. Were these the first science fiction? As I say, it all depends what you mean by science fiction, but it does suggest that people have been writing about the sorts of things we associate with science fiction for as long as they have been writing.

There's a name for this sort of stuff: it's referred to as "proto-sf", which sort of suggests it's not really science fiction. Well, there's all sorts of pretty amazing, pretty science-fictional ideas in all of these books, so make your own mind up.

The ranking

1
Frankenstein

Frankenstein

by Shelley, Mary

Buy on Amazon About this book

2
Utopia

Utopia

by Thomas More

Buy on Amazon About this book

5
Micromegas

Micromegas

by Francois Voltaire

Buy on Amazon About this book

10
New Atlantis

New Atlantis

by Francis Bacon

Buy on Amazon About this book

13
News From Nowhere

News From Nowhere

by Morris, William

Buy on Amazon About this book

14
Mundus Alter Et Idem

Mundus Alter Et Idem

by Joseph Hall

Buy on Amazon About this book

21
Somnium

Somnium

by Johannes Kepler

Buy on Amazon About this book